Bagels and Bialys is a no-frills bagel shop serving high quality bagels ...the right way! . If you live on Long Island, you know it's never easy to get a fresh, hot bagel after 8:00am. Luckily, this shop continues to make them throughout the morning. Reviewing the place solely on the bagels, I would give it 4 out of 5 stars.Now on to the service...this is an area that could use significant improvement. The older employees, who used to know what they were doing, have been replaced with poorly trained employees. I want to state that the owner of this bagel shop is extremely nice and hardworking, but he needs to work on his hiring skills. How do you write down a single bagel order on a notepad,...
Inflated prices for bagels! I ordered 6 bagels and a medium coffee and ended up being charged $22.50! That’s shocking. I had just moved and wanted to treat myself for Mother's Day, but it felt like I ended up paying Mother's Day prices instead. I was told the average price for a dozen bagels is around $17, and I think I paid more than that for just 6. If a medium coffee costs $4 to $4.50, that’s quite expensive too. I called the shop to express my concerns, but no one picked up, even though they were still supposed to be open! I recommend that you don’t make the same mistake I did—there are plenty of other good bagel shops around Albertson, Williston, Roslyn, and Mineola that would be happy...
I've been on the hunt for bagels on Long Island that remind me of my childhood, and I finally found the spot! As soon as you walk in, you can see them boiling the bagels in the back, and the smell is just like I remember. This place brings back memories of growing up in New York. The bagels are perfectly crisp on the outside, have a lovely chew, and are fluffy on the inside. Delicious! I'll definitely be coming back.
I witnessed a customer return their bagels because they received the wrong order, and the staff simply placed it back on the shelf without inspecting it thoroughly. It's concerning to think about where that bagel might end up and what the previous customer might have done with it.
Réservez une table maintenant
Favorite bagel place on Long Island! Perfect bagels for toasting if you like soft inside crispy outside (yumm)! Their veggie cream cheese is one of a kind too, very very good! Oh and don’t for get the muffins and chocolate croissant!! ? ?
Bagels were chewy and fresh, had sesame and onion bagels, scallion cream cheese. Counter staff were very nice and place was very clean. Would recommend.
This is the best bagel shop in the area! It's absolutely worth the trip to enjoy one of their freshly baked, hot bagels in the morning.
Excellent place to get bagels. It's more of a take out place but there are tables. And you can still buy your newspaper here! Friendly.
Réservez une table maintenant
The staff here are really friendly! We searched everywhere for pickled herring and were pleasantly surprised to find it here.
I've been coming here for the last year. Service is good, bagels are delicious. Love!
