Favorite pizza in Westchester. I grew up in Mount Vernon and was introduced at an early age to the authentic, delicious pizza in Fleetwood. A high bar was set. I then spent my adult years living in NYC and having access to Little Italy's best pizzeria's, among others. A higher bar was set. All that said, at Cosimo and Johnny's, everything is perfectly focused on quality and taste sauce and crust especially. The owner and staff are so accommodating and pizza positive. One time I was late picking up my pizza they close at 8:30 and waited for me until 8:40. Another time I was given a free pizza at the end of the night b/c someone didn't pick up their pizza. Now that is going above and beyond. I...
Great vibe in this neighborhood, family pizza parlor. Super friendly service. Great indoor and outdoor seating. Clean and happy place. Decent slice. Love their ham and cheese calzone. Closes early.Parking: Small limited parking lot on side. Depending on time, use adjacent lots with no issue. Really walkable location.
I travel extensively across the country, and surprisingly, this might just be the best slice of pizza I've ever had! It was a happy accident that I decided to stop by, and I'm so glad I did. I chose a slice with sausage and pepperoni, and the sausage could have easily been a meal on its own. Bravo! Food: 5/5
Everyone seems to have covered the Pizza but don’t sleep on their Calzones. Traditional Calzone is deep fried not baked…..excellent and the Broccoli Rabe Calzone is in a class by itself!!!!!!Thanx to Cosmo and family for bringing old school Louie and Ernie’s quality to Westchester.
Réservez une table maintenant
The staff is really friendly, but unfortunately, the pizza leaves much to be desired. I doubt Dave Portnoy would ever pay a visit. I've been there four or five times, primarily due to its proximity to my home. The pizza simply isn't good—poor dough and toppings. Sorry to say it!
One of the tastiest pizzas I've ever had! The thin crust is just perfect, with the ideal balance of sauce and cheese. Topped with some incredibly flavorful sausage and garlic, it's a delicious slice every time! Food: 5/5
I came here on a whim. I'm not a huge fan of pizza but this was delicious! The crust was light and crispy, as I like. I will be back to try other slices.
Best Margherita pizza. The sauce is absolute perfection. Nice helpful staff. Love the little bottles of wine in the cooler too! My new favorite place.
Réservez une table maintenant
Service friendly and good pizza. I will try other menu items on my next visit and will post an updateFood: 4/5
This place has a very old school vibe to it, a short menu and delicious pizza.Food: 5/5
