"LOVE Polly?s Pies. This was the first time I went into this location but everyone was so friendly. The entire place was spotless! Ordered a Banberry Pie to take home, since we were there traveling out of state. Highly recommend!"
I had higher expectations for the menu, but since it was our first visit and we came at night, I wasn't aware of the breakfast options. We decided to dine outside because it was a bit chilly inside, but it seemed like the staff forgot about us for a while. I ordered the fried chicken dinner with mashed potatoes, which was incredibly tasty, but the portions were on the small side and the chicken was a bit thin. Still, it was delicious! My daughter had the chicken fingers, and my partner ordered something else, but all the food was great. As we were leaving, the manager came out and offered us a complimentary apple pie for having to wait outside alone, and that made the whole meal worth it. It...
I expected a bit more variety on the menu, but since it was our first visit and evening time, we didn’t realize they also serve breakfast. We opted to sit outside because the indoor area was quite chilly, though we did feel a little ignored for a while. I ordered the fried chicken dinner with potatoes, which was very flavorful, even though the portions were somewhat small and the chicken pieces were a bit thin. Still, it was delicious. My daughter had the chicken fingers, and my partner picked a different dish. As we were leaving, the manager kindly surprised us with a complimentary apple cake, which made waiting outside worthwhile. That apple cake was the best I’ve ever had!
The sausage was dangerously undercooked. The manager told me he was going to make the kitchen aware and make sure they cook to temp every time. The potatoes were soggy. Like? really soggy. Coffee took 20 minutes? Gonna say it was a bad morning forthem, hopefully that?s not normal. I?m giving two stars because the manager owned the mistake very honestly and told me not topay a dime, and he said he hopes we return and have a better experience. He did take a while to get to us but I?d imagine therewere a few customers with similar issues today. Hope things are better next time I try them out. I?ve heard a lot of goodthings but I was disappointed today.
Now that I live nearby Polly's, I've been visiting for much more than just their pies. The breakfast is outstanding, featuring options like chicken fried steak, some of the best link sausage around, and a variety of baked goods such as muffins, cornbread, biscuits, and fresh-baked breads served as your toast side. For lunch, the macadamia-crusted halibut was a delightful treat. The burgers are excellent, and I’m excited to explore the rest of the menu.
Réservez une table maintenant
Fantastic! I always have a wonderful experience at Polly's Pies. The restaurant is well-managed and has a lovely atmosphere. The staff are dedicated and attentive, making every visit enjoyable. The food never fails to impress, and the desserts are exceptional—whether it's the iced coffee, cinnamon bun, or a slice of your favorite pie. I highly recommend trying the peach pie—you won’t be let down.
It didn't live up to the hype for me. I'm from Georgia, where we tend to prefer sweeter flavors! I've visited a few times to sample different pies but have been unable to buy any because of their limited availability. The staff is friendly, and the restaurant is clean and well-organized. Unfortunately, this place just doesn't suit my taste.
Great!Great!Great! I always enjoy my time at Pollys. Well run and great surroundings. I love their devoted, attentive, personnel. The food is never disappointing, and desert is the best weather it be the ice coffe, cinnamon bun, or pie of yourchoice, (try the peach pie) you will not be disappointed.
The food was quite good—the tuna practically melted in my mouth—but the cake selection was limited. The staff seemed a bit overwhelmed, making the service slower than ideal. I might check the cake options before returning, but I do appreciate the renovated space and the refreshed menu.
Réservez une table maintenant
The food was quite enjoyable—I had the tuna melt—but they were out of several pie options. The restaurant was also short-staffed, which left our waiter a bit overwhelmed. I may check on the pie availability before my next visit, but I really liked the renovations and the updated menu.
LOVE Polly?s Pies. This was the first time I went into this location but everyone was so friendly. The entire place was spotless! Ordered a Banberry Pie to take home, since we were there traveling out of state. Highly recommend!
