NEVER ORDER FROM THIS RESTAURANT READ!! This was the WORST experience ordering food in my entire life. My husband tried to place an order for a pizza. The male who took the order did not know the menu and after talking to my husband we realized within 60seconds we couldn 't eat the pizza because we have a food intolerance to tomatoe sauce. When my husband called back immediatelythe person working proceeded to LIE and tell us aggressively that within the 60 seconds between the first phone call and thesecond the pizza was already made. There is no way that a pizza could be made within that time frame. We then said we wanted arefund. He offered to make another pizza , but we clearly did not wan...
AVOID THIS RESTAURANT AT ALL COSTS! This was by far the worst food ordering experience I've ever had. My husband tried to order a pizza, but the man taking the order was completely unfamiliar with the menu. Within a minute, we realized we couldn’t eat the pizza because we have a tomato sauce intolerance. When my husband called back immediately to cancel, the employee lied aggressively, claiming the pizza was already made in that short time — which is impossible. We requested a refund, and although he offered to make another pizza, we didn’t want food from someone so rude, dishonest, and hostile. On top of that, the price was $38—significantly higher than the menu listed. After arguing for mo...
I called to place an order based on what I thought was their menu, but I later discovered that there is another menu listed below the Google overview that isn't theirs. This was particularly frustrating after following the link provided, which led nowhere. Now, onto the food: it was disappointing. If you're promoting New Haven-style pizza as a specialty, then what I received certainly didn't meet those expectations. It's passable, but not worth the price. Honestly, I'd prefer to eat Domino's. The specialty pizzas might be better, but I'm not willing to pay for that. I ordered my usual favorite, the Romano, and the sauce wasn't even on their real menu. The tomato sauce tasted like it came str...
I got the Breaking Bad treatment when I ordered for delivery (They didn 't slice the pizza, I had to do it myself). The pizza was half-pepperoni. That half was buried in grease. Each piece of pepperoni was curled up like a little tiny bowl, each onefilled to the brim with grease. The box was also covered in grease, to the point where I didn 't even want to handle it. I wish Itook pictures. And in spite of the fact the whole pizza was overcooked it was still delivered nearly ice cold (because it tookalmost an hour to arrive, and I 'm less than 5 minutes away). Hometown and Bakis are better options.
Réservez une table maintenant
I had a disappointing experience with the delivery from Anna's Prospect Pizza. They didn't slice the pizza, so I had to do it myself. I chose the half-pepperoni option, but it was drenched in grease. Each slice of pepperoni was curled up like a little bowl, filled to the brim with oil. The pizza box was so greasy that I hesitated to touch it. I regret not taking photos. Despite being overcooked, the pizza arrived nearly cold, taking almost an hour to get to me, even though I'm less than five minutes away. I would recommend Hometown or Bakis as better choices.
I moved to Prospect in December and decided to explore all the local pizza spots to find the best ones. I tried Anna's last because it had the lowest review score. I honestly don't understand how that's possible! I was incredibly surprised and can confidently say it has become our go-to pizzeria ever since! While all the pizza places in Prospect are good, Anna's truly stands out from the rest!
I ordered the spinach ricotta specialty pie and it was incredible. As a huge fan of white pies, they definitely get it right here. The crust was excellent too, which is always a key indicator of a great pizza. We began with buffalo chicken eggrolls, a perfect appetizer. Four generously sized eggrolls were just enough! We’ll definitely be returning.
Before ordering from Anna's Prospect Pizza, make sure you have the right website from the four options available (it might be a bit tricky to find!). Also, a quick note: the official website linked to the restaurant isn't updated with the latest prices. I would recommend considering another pizza place instead.
Réservez une table maintenant
Got the spinach ricotta specialty pie. Absolutely killer. I'm a big white pie fan and they nail the style for sure. Great crust as well, which is the telltale sign of a good pie. Started off with some buff chick eggrolls, perfect starter. 4 good sizedeggrolls were plenty! We will be back
I love their food and I've never had a bad experience. It's my go-to pizza place.
