"The entire menu at Athenian Garden was outstanding. The waiting staff were very attentive and friendly. Despite it being a birthday celebration, we weren't charged for the dessert because the owner mentioned they use a lighter instead of candles."
My sister and I both worked here in the past, and we frequently come back to savor some comforting dishes. Each visit feels like being welcomed by family. The food is genuinely authentic Greek, and in my opinion, it’s the finest in Florida—surpassing even Acropolis and Tarpon Springs! This family-run restaurant has been thriving for more than 20 years. The food, ambiance, and service are all exceptional. Be sure to try the Aegean Chicken and Avgolemono soup, and definitely don’t miss the Greek salad! We absolutely adore this place!
I have eaten at Athenian Gardens on 22nd several times. For the most part the food is amazing. Entrees I have ordered were excellent. Sadly, the Greek salad is reliably poor. They seem to use packaged salad mix, canned beets, and once they used mozzarella cheese instead of feta. One time there was no cheese at all. Go ahead and eat here, just be aware that the salad might not be what you expect.
This is more American-Greek than Greek-American food. The Tabbouleh was 95% wheat with almost no parsley. The Gyro was seasoned, but it lacked any particular taste (if this makes any sense). The rice was also seasoned, but it didn't have any taste at all. The Greek salad was good, and so was the complimentary bread. The service was good too--my iced tea was refilled thrice and was never empty.
This used to be my go to. Recently went there and got my Greek salad and within 20 minutes I was sick. Enough to call 911. Then 3 weeks later tried again and got sick to my stomach. Son felt nauseated also. Don't know if they cross contaminated or not cleaning their vegetables. None the less I won't be going there anymore. Like I said this WAS my favorite place before.
Réservez une table maintenant
The Moussaka was quite delicious, but it was just barely warm. The soup of the day, Chicken Orzo, was decent but also served lukewarm, so I had to send it back. The Greek salad that accompanied the meal was tasty, though I only got one olive. However, the potato salad was excellent, and I always request extra scoops of that. Overall, the service was very good.
I have eaten several times in Athenian Gardens. Most of the food is amazing. Entries I ordered were excellent. Unfortunately, the Greek salad is reliable bad. They seem to use packed salad mix, canned, and once they use mozzarella cheese instead of feta. Once there was no cheese at all. Go on and eat here, just note that the salad is not what you expect.
Athenian Garden is the Greek restaurant they didn’t even realize they were looking for. The staff were incredibly friendly and eager to assist with all our questions. The food was phenomenal—freshly prepared to order and served hot. Everyone loved their dishes. I will definitely visit again whenever I’m in the area.
The Moussaka was very good, but it was hardly hot enough, the soup of the day was Chicken Orzo it was good, but was barley even warm had to send it back. The Greek salad that comes with the meal was good only 1 olives, but the pots of potato salad were very good I always order extra pots. The service was very good.
Réservez une table maintenant
Athenian Garden is the Greek you've been looking for and didn't know. The staff where super friendly and eager to help with any questions we had. The food was phenomenal. Cooked fresh for our order and delivered piping hot. Everyone loved their dishes. Will definitely visit again if I'm in the area.
The entire menu at Athenian Garden was outstanding. The waiting staff were very attentive and friendly. Despite it being a birthday celebration, we weren't charged for the dessert because the owner mentioned they use a lighter instead of candles.
Salade De Pommes De Terre
Salade De Poulet Athénienne
Soupe À La Crème De Tomates
Guivetsi (Lamb Shank Orzo)
Baklava Dipped In Choclate
